An important question

As with almost anything of importance in Alaska, the question of whether it is constitutional for the Legislature to forward-fund K-12 education appears headed to court.

At its core is this: Can a Legislature appropriate money this year – money it does not have – to fund education for next year? The Legislature did just that last year when it set aside $1.7 billion in funding for education.

Does that bind Gov. Mike Dunleavy this year? Does it bind future lawmakers and future governors to decisions they had nothing to do with?

The House and Senate believe they can forward-fund; the governor, not so much. He says it is unconstitutional. The chambers have authorized the Legislative Council to sue him to resolve the issue.

Dunleavy has suggested lawmakers repeal the $1.7 billion in forward-funding and include education money in this year’s budget, which remains unapproved. Lawmakers have refused to do that.

A court will have to decide whether the Legislature’s constitutionally mandated power of appropriation includes forward-funding. It will have to weigh that against the constitution’s strictures on binding future Legislatures.

If the courts say lawmakers do, in fact, have power to forward-fund government, it will allow the Legislature to fund departments, programs and agencies for perhaps years in advance, even though they have no money to appropriate at the time.

It also severely would limit the governor’s power and tip the scales toward the legislative branch of government.

It is a serious question, a question with huge ramifications, that must be answered. – and soon.

One Response to An important question

  1. Morrigan May 29, 2019 at 1:12 pm

    Drilling further into the “core” if one may, should productive Alaskans concede authority to the union-management cabal which is Alaska’s education industry to require the Legislature to forward-fund K-12 education?
    In simpler terms for public-school alumnae, should Alaska’s education industry be able to make the Legislature sue the governor to get more money?
    If the answer is a predictably rousing (expl del) NO!, the next article on the subject might suggest how productive Alaskans can de-horn, geld our overly frisky education industry.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For information, sizing, and rates of banner advertising space we have available, please e-mail Mark Hopkin at, or call him at (907) 276-4262.